A leading global group that advocates for a standard electric vehicle charging connector and port pushed back Nov. 29 against Tesla plans to establish a North American charging standard, saying it doesn’t go far enough in spanning the commonly established equipment used by most major electric vehicle manufacturers.
The Charging Interface Initiative (CharIN) Inc., and its CharIN North America chapter, issued a statement calling on key players pursuing a universal charging connector — similar to a standardized fuel pump nozzle — to focus on speeding up and consolidating the market for electrification instead of causing consumer confusion and delaying EV adoption.
Tesla announced in a Nov. 11 blog post its proprietary North American Charging Standard (NACS) that opens its widely used connector to non-Tesla EV drivers, citing that the equipment has no moving parts and is half the size and twice as powerful as the Combined Charging System (CCS) connector advocated by CharIN. It also reports that NACS vehicles outnumber CCS ones two to one, and Tesla's supercharging network has 60% more NACS posts than all the CCS-equipped networks combined.
“Network operators already have plans in motion to incorporate NACS at their chargers, so Tesla owners can look forward to charging at other networks without adapters,” according to the Tesla blog post. “Similarly, we look forward to future electric vehicles incorporating the NACS design and charging at Tesla’s North American supercharging and destination charging networks.”
In response, CharIN stated, “CCS has gone through many years of rigorous standardization processes, which is a required activity for any new standard proposal. After a decade of collaborative work, the domestic and international EV industry has aligned around CCS.”
A Long List of OEMs Vested in CCS
CharIN also cited the following facts and arguments in favor of continued promotion of the CCS equipment:
- Nearly 300 domestic and international CharIN members are using or investing in CCS.
- Most major domestic and international automakers are using and supporting CCS, including Audi, BMW, Daimler, Ford Motor Company, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai/Kia, Lucid, Lotus, Mazda, MAN, Mercedes-Benz, Navistar, New Flyer, Nikola, Nissan, PSA Groupe, Proterra, Renault, Rivian, Scania, Stellantis, Subaru, Suzuki, Tata Motors, Tesla, Toyota, Volvo, and Volkswagen.
- In the U.S., CCS is used in over 50 passenger vehicle models.
- CCS can connect to all AC charging stations without an adapter via the J1772 standard.
- Worldwide, there are 61,000 DC fast chargers using the CCS connector, compared to 40,000 Tesla Super chargers according to data published by CharIN and Tesla.
- In North America (including the U.S. and Canada) there are 18,880 CCS connectors compared to 18,405 Tesla Super charger connectors and 178,926 J1172 connectors compared to 15,529 Tesla destination connectors, according to recent Plugshare data (includes public and restricted use).
Delays and Disruptions in EV Adoption
Tesla’s proposed NACS would have to face the hurdles of passing through an established standardization process via standards bodies, such as ISO, IEC, and/or SAE, CharIN stated. The challenges of creating new standards or changing the existing standards could involve significant market disruptions, with companies diverting energy and resources into a different standard that could take up to six years to develop.
It would also delay the regulatory and policy processes underway to standardize charging and overall electrification, resulting in local, state and federal governing bodies postponing vital decisions on charging infrastructure and a unified approach to electrification, CharIN said.
CharIN supports a rigorous peer review process in developing standards, such as ISO, IEC, and SAE. The CCS standard, including connectors and related communications protocols, is a genuine international benchmark vetted through the standardization process that could end up not matching the configurations of Tesla’s NACS.
A CNN Business report posted the day following Tesla’s announcement said it is not yet clear if other EV manufacturers and charging networks could cooperate with the company’s plans.
“We strongly encourage Tesla, as a CharIN member, to work with CharIN’s membership base, the standards organizations, and others to accelerate the adoption of a fully interoperable EV charging solution to transition to electric vehicles more quickly,” CharIN stated.
CharIN is the largest global association focused on the electrification of all forms of transportation based on the seamless and interoperable charging experience enabled by the Combined Charging System (CCS) and the Megawatt Charging System (MCS). CCS and MCS are considered the global standards for charging vehicles of all kinds.