Charged Fleet Logo

EV Parity with ICE Vehicles - Are We Making Progress?

J.D. Power's new Electric Vehicle Index uses data and analytics to measure the path to EV adoption and how far we've come to parity with gas-powered vehicles.

EV Parity with ICE Vehicles - Are We Making Progress?

J.D. Power announced the introduction of the J.D. Power's new analytics tool will keep track of the U.S. EV market.

Photo: Canva

3 min to read


J.D. Power introduced on Jan 17 the J.D. Power EV Index, an analytics tool to track the growing electric vehicle market in the U.S.

Each month, the index will arrive at one number (on a 100-point scale) to make it easy to understand the progress to parity of EVs with traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, according to the company's news release.

Ad Loading...

J.D. Power said the sub-category numbers will represent all the roadblocks to parity. The EV Index score is 47 (based on the most recent available data from November 2022), with some categories improving and others declining during the 12-month pilot period. The EV Index score and accompanying analysis will be available monthly. 

“Vehicle electrification has industry leaders grappling with billion-dollar decisions, and hyper-detailed data and analytics will help guide their decision-making,” said Elizabeth Krear, VP of electric vehicle practice at J.D. Power. “We’ve created a smart and dynamic way to capture how the EV marketplace is performing in relation to gas-powered vehicles, and the index provides a heightened level of detail never seen before in this arena.” 

Millions of data points are aggregated into six specific categories to make up the EV Index: 

  • Interest—This factor measures the potential commitment to purchasing an EV based on the voice of the customer and online behavioral data. The Interest score is 32, up eight points from a year ago in the pilot phase, due largely to the growing number of EV models available or soon coming to market.

  • Availability—This factor measures the proportion of new-vehicle buyers who have an EV purchase option that meets their buying needs, reflective of factors like price, manufacturer origin, segment, and other inputs. The Availability score is 30, up 12 points year over year due largely to the ongoing introduction of EV models into new and important segments.

  • Adoption—This factor measures the proportion of new-vehicle buyers who purchase an EV, relative to those with a viable substitute meeting their needs. The Adoption score is 22, down four points from a year ago primarily because the expansion of EV model availability is outpacing EV retail share.

  • Affordability—This factor measures the total cost of ownership of an EV compared with the ICE segment average (after tax credits, rebates, incentives, operating costs, and residual values—for both purchase and lease transactions). The Affordability score is 84, down 12 points year over year as EV prices have increased and 15 models were disqualified beginning in August when the Inflation Reduction Act’s North America manufacturing criteria kicked in. The Affordability score is expected to change based on January 2023 data as the manufacturers’ volume cap is lifted, but vehicle price thresholds and income limits are factored into the purchase of an EV. Leasing, which is currently at 10%, also is expected to grow because the criteria are less restrictive for leasing.

  • Infrastructure—This factor measures the availability, location, speed, quality, and reliability of EV charging compared with gas stations for ICE vehicles. The Infrastructure score is 27, down four points year over year primarily because the volume of EV units in operation is outpacing the rate of reliable charger installations.

  • Experience—This factor measures owners’ overall satisfaction with their EVs, including appeal, quality, durability, range, and sales and service experiences, as compared with an ICE vehicle equivalent. The Experience score is 89, down two points from a year ago due largely to declining satisfaction with the EV sales experience. 

The EV Index for the U.S. market enables industry stakeholders to navigate the EV environment with real-time data that is plugged into a web-based portal. The portal is equipped with a dashboard and a custom query tool that can help stakeholders make more reliable decisions.  

Ad Loading...

The new service also includes substantially increased data granularity in which metrics are available at the national, regional, state, and Designated Market Area (DMA) levels, and can be broken down by segment, brand, and model. 

Originally posted on Automotive Fleet

More Electric Vehicles

A Charged Fleet graphic with a transparent rear-view background of a chargin Tesla
Electric Vehiclesby Faith HowellSeptember 16, 2026

EV Charging Use Is Outpacing Infrastructure Growth

ChargePoint’s 2026 Charging Forward Report points to rising charger use, higher-powered charging, commercial vehicle electrification, and energy-management technology. Here’s what fleets should know.

Read More →
Mark Holland headshot for 2026 leadership update
Electric Vehiclesby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 10, 2026

EV Realty Names Henrik Holland President as Charging Platform Expands

The former Prologis Mobility and Shell executive will help expand EV Realty’s truck charging business and move its power-first infrastructure model into autonomous vehicle depots and other fleet sectors.

Read More →
Three GreenPower Type A Nano BEAST electric school buses.
Electric Vehiclesby Elora HaynesSeptember 9, 2026

GreenPower Expands New Mexico EV Pilot With Larger Buses, V2G Testing

After logging more than 17,000 electric miles in the first year, New Mexico’s statewide pilot is moving into its second phase with larger vehicles, continued charging evaluations, and more.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A black, white, and yellow Charged Fleet podcast logo with text over top
Electric VehiclesSeptember 4, 2026

Can EV-as-a-Service Help Fleets Scale Electrification?

Sustainability Partners CEO Adam Cain explains how matching EVs, charging infrastructure, and duty cycles can help fleets scale electrification.

Read More →
Illustration of an electric fleet vehicle connected to a charging station with the text “Electric Vehicles... As a Service?”
Electric VehiclesSeptember 1, 2026

How EV-as-a-Service Is Moving Fleets Beyond Pilots

Adam Cain, president and CEO of Sustainability Partners, explains how EV-as-a-service can help fleets scale deployments by addressing duty-cycle requirements and charging challenges. 

Read More →
A Charged Fleet and mobility powerhouse acquisition
Electric Vehiclesby Amanda HuggettAugust 20, 2026

PowerFlex, The Mobility House Join Forces to Advance Fleet Electrification

Two EV charging providers are joining forces to deliver a broader portfolio of energy management and fleet electrification solutions.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Ford Fathom on track facility
Electric Vehiclesby StaffAugust 18, 2026

Ford Retools Louisville Plant for Fathom Electric Truck Production

Ford's $2 billion Louisville Assembly Plant overhaul introduces a three-part assembly process for the Fathom midsize electric truck, with production scheduled to begin in 2027.

Read More →
green car with text over it reading The Current State of Fleet Electrification
Electric VehiclesAugust 13, 2026

Merchants Fleet Reports 290M EV Miles as Fleets Navigate Changing Electrification Market

From millions in operating savings to hundreds of millions of EV miles, Merchants Fleet’s latest report reveals what’s working and what’s changing in fleet electrification.

Read More →
Three speakers participate in a panel discussion at the Road to 2028 Summit Series. A man in a gray suit speaks into a microphone while two other panelists listen on stage beneath a "Road to 2028 Summit Series" sign.
Electric VehiclesAugust 12, 2026

California District Commits to Electrify 25% of School Bus Fleet by 2028

One of the nation's largest school bus electrification projects to date demonstrates how grants, charging infrastructure, and public-private partnerships can help fleets transition to EVs at scale.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Futuristic silver three-wheeled Aptera solar electric vehicle drives along a palm-lined road, featuring integrated solar panels, aerodynamic bodywork, enclosed front wheels, and a streamlined teardrop-shaped cabin.
Electric Vehiclesby News/Media ReleaseAugust 10, 2026

Aptera Orders Bodies and Chassis for Its First 40 Production Vehicles

Aptera Motors Corp. has issued purchase orders for the major structural components of its first 40 vehicles, and body and chassis components are expected to begin arriving in October.

Read More →