Charged Fleet Logo

Uber Could Be Violating Antitrust Laws, Judge Says

A case brought against Uber by Los Angeles-based Diva Limousine argues that Uber's business model — as it pertains to drivers — financially harms its competitors.

June 23, 2019
Uber Could Be Violating Antitrust Laws, Judge Says

In 2018, the California Supreme Court made a ruling making it more difficult for companies to classify workers as independent contractors.

Photo via Pixabay.

1 min to read


Uber's practice of designating its drivers as independent contractors may be a violation of antitrust laws, according to a federal judge.

Bloomberg Law reports that Judge Edward Chen of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, who is currently hearing a case brought against Uber by Los Angeles-based Diva Limousine, also ruled that Uber's business model — as it pertains to drivers — could harm its competitors. In court, Diva's lawyers argued that alleged misclassification of drivers could save the company as much as $500 million annually in California alone.

Ad Loading...

In 2018, the California Supreme Court made a ruling making it more difficult for companies to classify workers as independent contractors. It also named misclassification of employment as a type of unfair competition.

However, Chen's ruling is not a final decision in this case. The judge dismissed one of Diva's complaints against Uber due to jurisdictional issues and other legal arguments.

Lawyers for the limo company have 30 days to refile an updated complaint before the case can move forward.

Originally posted on Auto Rental News

More Legal/Legislative

A Lucid Gravity parked at a charging station with a charging cord inserted into the port.

Used EVs Set Wholesale Sales Record In Q1

Rising gas prices may have boosted demand last month, as dealers pursued potential opportunities with more affordable used EVs.

Read More →
Charged Fleet Off Peak logo thumbnail with symbolic lightning bolt.
Electric Vehiclesby Martin RomjueApril 3, 2026

OEMS Expose Overdue EV Truths

Recent announcements from two automakers underscore a significant shift in the electric vehicle market, driven by EV losses and changing strategies. [VIDEO}

Read More →
Three lightning bolts serve as the primary logo for The Off Peak video series.
Electric Vehiclesby Martin RomjueJanuary 21, 2026

The Freedom Era For Electric Vehicles

Season 2 Episode 1 of The Off-Peak premieres as the electric vehicle market no longer benefits from federal tax credits that expired at the end of Q3 2024. What does this mean for the future appeal of EVs?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Collage of drivers charging electric vehicles at public and home charging stations, with a large green plug icon centered over the images.
Legal/Legislativeby News/Media ReleaseJanuary 13, 2026

New Research Shows Renewed Potential And Tolerance For EVs

A new EV consumer survey finds partisan resistance is easing, but concerns around cost, incentives, and charging access still shape buyer interest.

Read More →
A nighttime aerial close-up of a Ford F-150 Lightning all-electric pickup truck with surround lighting parked on a grass field.
Electric Vehiclesby Martin RomjueDecember 29, 2025

2025 Generated Big Headlines In The EV World

The EV industry entered a new more nuanced phase defined by realities and practical outcomes after a few years of grand visions, media hype, and bold investments.

Read More →
A Fleet Forward graphic highlighting John's Boesel's retirement at this year's award ceremony on October 22.
Electric Vehiclesby Faith HowellNovember 5, 2025

John Boesel Recognized at 2025 Fleet Forward Conference

Bobit recognized John Boesel, CEO of Calstart, who is retiring after over three decades of service.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Map of the U.S. showing EV federal tax credits ending September 30, 2025, with $7,500 credit for 30D and $40,000 credit for 45W. Includes event markers for Irvine, July 22, and Somerset, September 9.
Electric Vehiclesby Chris BrownAugust 11, 2025

Final Push for Federal EV Incentives Highlighted at Fleet Forward Tour NJ Stop

Fleet managers in the Northeast will have a timely opportunity to take action on electric vehicle purchases at the upcoming Fleet Forward Tour stop in Somerset, NJ, on Sept. 9.

Read More →
Electric Vehiclesby Martin RomjueJuly 25, 2025

Latest Hard Realities, Top Pressures For Electric Fleets

Speakers and experts at Fleet Forward: The Tour shared hands-on, hard-won insights on how fleet operations are handling tariffs, EV charging, rules and regs, and safety issues.

Read More →
Graphic showing seminar speakers.
Legal/Legislativeby StaffJuly 15, 2025

Mobility 360 Panel to Define the Fleet Industry’s Next Tipping Point

At the 2025 Fleet Forward Conference, experts in capital, policy, and data will assess which trends are transforming fleet.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An EV charging with the California flag, EPA seal, and Supreme Court seal overlaid, representing clean vehicle policy debate.

Ruling Could Undercut California’s Zero-Emission Vehicle Authority

The Supreme Court decision gives fuel producers the leeway to challenge an EV mandate waiver — raising new questions about the future of clean vehicle rules on fleet electrification.

Read More →